The Persistence of Market Fragmentation and Liquidity
More than half of U.S. equity volume executes away from exchanges that display prices, and the remainder is spread across seventeen exchanges. Whether this dispersion of trading deteriorates market quality is disputed in theory and unresolved in the data. Using a decade of high-frequency data for 1,758 highly traded stocks, I document that both the allocation of a stock's trading across venues and its liquidity are long memory processes with common components. Previous econometric specifications do not accurately identify the relation between fragmentation and liquidity given these properties. I find that competition among lit exchanges is associated with tighter spreads at short horizons and wider spreads at longer horizons, with deeper books at every horizon. A stock's order flow migration off-exchange is associated with wider lit spreads and thinner lit depth at every horizon, while market-wide off-exchange migration is associated with deeper books.